So, I did an interview for CBR. Nice fellow named Robert Taylor conducted it. You can read it here if you’re so inclined.
I did something I normally would never do in it, which is I actually went so far as to criticize my fellow 52 writers as well as myself. Minor criticism, to be sure, and nothing that I think was particularly dangerous, edgy, daring, or otherwise hurtful.
But we writers are such a sensitive goddamn lot I’m now beginning to wish I hadn’t said anything other than the standard, “These guys are the GREATEST!!!” I haven’t received any angry calls, mind; Waid hasn’t come after me with his well-honed axe, and Geoff hasn’t rung up with a “dude, not cool.” All the same, I’ve made myself uncomfortable by doing this, and now I’m left to wonder why.
And it’s not that hard to see, frankly. These guys are my peers, and more, I honestly think of them as my friends (my very dear friends, in fact). I’d hate to think I said anything to hurt their feelings, anything that could be misconstrued (even given the lengths I went to in the interview to assure that precisely that didn’t happen) as mean-spirited or lacking respect for them or their craft.
But that’s only part of it. The other part of it is that I’ve broken an Unwritten Law, one that stretches all the way back to my first writing classes. I’ve offered criticism, and even if it was constructive and mild, it opens me up for the same.
Which is bullshit. The paradox of writing for a living is that people are going to read what you write, and some of them (maybe a lot of them) Are Not Going To Like It.
You have to learn to deal with it, and the key word here is ‘learn’ and not ‘deal.’ It’s an ongoing process, and I don’t know a single writer who isn’t stung by criticism of their work, no matter how minor, infantile, or incompetent the source. It may not be a major sting, it may not last, but I continue to find it amazing that some Net Troll who offers his unsolicited and uneducated “review” of my work can bother me almost as much as a bad review from, say, Kirkus.
Another thing that comes with the territory.
I’ve thought about this a lot, in fact, and I’ve come to the conclusion that the only writers out there who are not affected by criticism in some way, shape, or form are writers I want nothing to do with. Because those are the writers who have no doubts about their work, which in turn means they believe their work has no room for improvement.
Writing is a growth form. You MUST get better at it, or at least you must strive to. More than anything, believing you know everything you need to know, that you do not need to hone your craft further, that you do not need, for instance, an editor…that’s the kiss of fucking death.
And I never want to be that writer. That writer scares me.